There’s something almost primal about the promise of unlimited seafood – especially when that promise includes premium offerings like lobster. When I heard that Crabhouse Brooklyn had an all-you-can-eat seafood dinner featuring these coveted crustaceans, I knew I had to investigate. What I discovered was nothing short of a seafood lover’s paradise.
First Impressions
Walking into Crabhouse Brooklyn, you’re immediately greeted by the restaurant’s maritime charm. Weathered wood panels, nautical accents, and the unmistakable aroma of butter and garlic set the stage for what’s to come. The restaurant strikes a balance between casual comfort and upscale dining – perfect for a feast where you’ll inevitably be using your hands.
The all-you-can-eat premium seafood dinner is offered daily, and reservations are absolutely essential.
The Lobster Experience
Let’s address the star of the show right away: the lobster. The meat was sweet, tender, and impossibly fresh. What makes this deal extraordinary is that you can request additional lobster once you’ve finished your first. Yes, unlimited lobster – though I found that one whole lobster coupled with the parade of other seafood was quite substantial.
Beyond Lobster: A Sea of Options
While the lobster rightfully claims the spotlight, the supporting cast deserves equal praise. The all-you-can-eat experience includes: crab legs, oysters, clams, shrimp, salmon, scallops, beef & broccoli, and so much more!
What impressed me most was that despite the “unlimited” concept, quality was never sacrificed. Each new round of seafood arrived fresh and perfectly prepared.
Ambiance and Service
What could easily become a chaotic feeding frenzy is instead managed with remarkable efficiency. The staff was friendly and accommodating, and also moved with purpose between tables, timing the delivery of each course perfectly.
The restaurant buzzes with energy – the satisfying crack of lobster shells, laughter, and occasional gasps of delight create a soundtrack of culinary pleasure. Yet somehow, even at capacity, the noise level never becomes overwhelming.
Value
Seafood Buffet (not including lobsters)
Adult Price $80
Children Age 8-11 $30
Age 3-7 $15
Lobster Buffet (lobsters + everything else in Seafood Buffet)
Adult Price $115
Children Age 8-11 $40
Age 3-7 $20
Same Price Everyday (drinks are not included in the buffet price)
Final Thoughts
Crabhouse Brooklyn’s all-you-can-eat premium seafood dinner delivers on its ambitious promise. It transforms what could be a gimmicky concept into a genuine celebration of the sea’s bounty. The attention to quality, the thoughtful preparation, and the generous portions make this one of Brooklyn’s most compelling dining experiences for seafood lovers.
Just remember to book well in advance, arrive hungry, and pace yourself. The ocean’s treasures deserve to be savored, even when they’re unlimited.
Note: This review reflects my experience in March 2025. Pricing and offerings may change seasonally.